shuga's Blog

Granted, both are wrong, but I don't think you can compare someone posing on a porn site ("Daddy's Little Girls") appearing to masturbate (Frenchie) to some photos that were probably taken by a friend screwing around that were tastfully done (Antonella). Should she be booted? Yeah, because she can't sing, but not for a few photos...that's just my take.

I personally think it was stupid for someone to get booted off of AI for posing on a porn site anyway. GENERALLY SPEAKING:
EVERYONE has a skeleton or two or three or more in their closet, it's just a matter as to whether anyone finds it. No one is perfect and EVERYONE in their lifetime makes a bad choice or two or more, including all the self-righteous smug arrogant people out there that pretend they do, and have never done, no wrong. It's just a matter of once a bad choice is made, whether or not that person learns from the mistake. Rather than just focusing on one's mistake, it would be better to also put focus to whether or not that person has learned from his/her mistake. If the lesson is learned, that counts for something.

Antonella's photos were tasteful? I think not, especially since she posed for them at the WWII Memorial. No matter where they were taken, they were crude, lewd, and raunchy. The "gift for her BF" excuse doesn't cut it at all. That's just as BLEEP and self-degrading as doing it for a porn site, and once it's captured on film it IS porn.

No matter how you slice it...it was wrong..you can't be gone with one and not the other...it's a shame that it's really going down like this...but it is...one thing for sure Ms. Frenchie is doing fine...making her mark on Broadway....Antonella let's just pray that this is her last week...my ears can stand the pain...

thank you nessie... I didnt want to be the one to say but we all know what the deal is... it is just sad... Even if she doesnt get booted off i hoep this is her last week.. She cant sing to save her soul lol... I dont think any of the contestants this year are that great anyway except for Lakisha and Melinda.

I can just about guarantee that Antonella wont be booted off the show for awhile for a few reasons that have NOTHING to do with her singing ability. Despite its best effort, AI is a popularity contest no matter how much they want it to be a singing competition.
Teenaged boys like Antonella's looks and are intrigued by the pictures on the 'net. Unfortunately, teen girls aspire to what they consider her present "lofty" position and probably see her pictures as an option for them to get their 15 minutes of fame. Forget all the hoopla about the WWII Memorial aspect, I will bet you that most of these kids dont know jack about that war and dont care either.(I said on another blog that they should be upset about this (my dad is a WWII vet), but when I thought about it, it occurred to me that they are probably clueless)
The sad part of this is that the girl CANT SING. But she will stay on the show for every reason except her singing ability (or lack thereof).

Thanks for saying it Nessie. I watched Frenchie's interview last night on Bill O'Reilly last night and RESPECT to Frenchie for how she carries(ed) herself. When Bill asked her about the race thing, she tactfully stated that she was not going to state her opinion re; that on his show and didn't answer. Which Bill then put the words in her mouth by saying "ok so it's a race thing....."
She also made it plain she was 19 and was only trying to pay for college and wasn't thinking about anything else. She also stated the producers of AI flip flopped on the porn issue. Finally, like she said, if we were all judged for our actions as 19 year olds....